Lies, damn lies, entrepreneurship and Africans supporting each other

Posted by
Munyaradzi Gwatidzo

Munyaradzi Gwatidzo, The founder and CEO of Astro Mobile

The life of a startup entrepreneurship is anything but easy. Anywhere in the world really. What is considered the normal failure rate is nothing short of scary and alarming.

Very close to all startup companies are headed for failure before they can become anything, again, anywhere in the world. The odds are stacked against the entrepreneur so much, any break anyone can give them is welcome relief. Anywhere in the world. But more so here. If the local tech startup ecosystem is to improve, we need to support each other.

Over last week, after reporting that Astro – a new local startup company in devices and exploring Software as a Service platforms – appeared to be lying about their products, some of the feedback we got from readers, was that it was wrong for us to mention this. That we are what’s wrong with the tech startup ecosystem as we are just pulling them down. That a startup has many struggles already without worrying about bloggers scrutinising them. The Astro founder himself, Munyaradzi Gwatidzo, went to the extent of showing us examples of glowing articles penned by other bloggers. Why can’t you be like them, being the message.

We love startups. We talk about them everyday at the office. Astro happens to be one of the few we talk about more often in terms of how they see the future that their competition seem oblivious to. That they are bold in the steps they take and raise money for it. Astro are not trying to be the best device company, they are working to be a platform company. They have made attempts and are working on payments, on a music market and we think streaming as well. They see a broadband everywhere future where smart TVs will be in average income families, and they are positioning already for that future. They are working to disrupt DStv’s market dominance in the future. We respect such boldness and risk taking in a local startup.

But then the lies come. Astro tells a room full of the media, ICT Ministry officials, Investors and key customers that they have invested in 8 months of R&D to come up with the world’s thinnest phone, which turns out to just be fables. The room applauds them; ministers, permanent secretaries, academics and the few investors that local startups are chasing, all marvel at the strides Zimbabwean innovators are making in spite of the odds.

advertisement

That the startup is making a fool out of everyone is a small issue of course. The bigger issue is where do they draw the line? What else are they lying about and who else are they lying to? And what precedent are they setting in the ecosystem? And if we all line up as a herd supporting blatant lying, really, what ecosystem are we even talking about?

And when all this nonsense blows up in their face, like it has done before many times (even for Gwatidzo himself) how will this affect other entrepreneurs looking for support from the ecosystem. If local investors get burnt by these lies how does that affect other startups raising funds locally?

The frustrating thing, and what we don’t get yet, is why Astro has to lie in the first place. Slapping a company’s logo on phones designed and produced in China is itself not wrong. It’s done all the time even by the mobile operators. It’s a brilliant model as Astro doesn’t need to invest in R&D yet in these early stages when they don’t have the money for it. They can build a strong brand on this without needing to lie.

They don’t need to talk about how they design phones and how their innovative design is now the thinnest phone in the world. There are many creative ways to play with the marketing words without blatant lying and misleading the market.

Lying doesn’t help technology entrepreneurship locally. It hurts it.



70 Comments

  1. Anonymous says:

    aaaah..havasi maface etuma laptops twainzi nhava here ava

    1. [email protected] says:

      Whats more hilarious is that Gvt is falling for the same tricks.

      They were shame faced after cheerleading Nhava which went on to rip-off a great number of people including the civil service whom they had encouraged to buy into it.

      If Technical people or platforms like Techzim do not scrutinize such things, what are they there for?

      To cheer lead false claims?!!!!

      How has focus shifted from overt lies to not supporting business? Shall we sit back and watch people misrepresent our profession?

      If not brought up today, it was definitely going to be brought up later? And guess who’ll be in the firing line:
      – the Government which you will have misled
      – the computer profession in Zimbabwe( hello, CSZ)
      – and lastly, the happy liar who would have made their fill of money.

      Thank-goodness I dont write for TechZim, otherwise am as blunt as they come, would’ve stripped them down to their false-selves.

      Nonsense, cry babies!

      Nxxaaaa!

      1. chirau says:

        I used to think [email protected] was white

        1. [email protected] says:

          Nzveeee…………..!!

        2. lavhu says:

          why? I am curious.

  2. Munashe says:

    Originality should be the innovation.

  3. takudzwa says:

    you really hate these guys passionately hey

  4. mukuru263 says:

    https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=10152371785492171

    Hope Mr Chanakira did’nt invest in a lot of money.

  5. tanatswa says:

    its typical of us africans to pull each other down, astro and gtel are doing a great job,whats so speacial everyday apple sumsung huwei are always copying each other and all claim to have the slimest phopnes.live astro alone .

    1. Anonymous says:

      I used to have a have a gtel, nice android phones

  6. mukuru263 says:

    For the record, i do not have a problem with Gtel, G-Tide or the other chinese phone companies in Zimbabwe. It’s the Astro lies that piss me off.
    Please look at that advert.
    Seriously?????????????????

    1. sililbaziso says:

      but thez lots of these videos going around guys or even pics especially for this joke ‘unotoshaya kuti zvirikumbofamba sei. Whats wrong with astro doing the same. So many adverts and pics and songs that are personalised in zimbabwe guys come on lets stop the hating and support these companies. Techzim its time u start supporting local companies and not destroy. From what iv seen in all your posts about local sme’s all ur doing is destroying them. Why cant u ever have anything good to say for once at least about one company and show some support you’ll be amazed at what Zimbabwe can produce. Try it guys. STOP THE HATING

      1. Braddock says:

        my friend, business isnt your strongest suite i see, lies are lies, period. I have followed Techzim for 4 years now. Simply because they critically analise all their stories and bring them forward. Bravo to Techzim. Astro is hurting its own reputation by lying. Samsung and Apple play with words, they dont openly lie about their devices!

      2. [email protected] says:

        You think you’re being supportive?

        You’re worse than our hatefulness to lying.

        You are the type who would cheer a friend into a volcano singing “We are the world…We are the children”

        Mana ng’ku tshele ke sis/bhuti silibaziso. Akwenziwa njalo. Esikwenzayo yikuqondisa umuntu. As’ngeke samjwayeza ukuthi eklabalale etshel’abantu ukuthi wakhi ndizamtshina ngotshane.

        You, my friend, are worse than our vile reactions.

  7. tanatswa says:

    the guys are smart and innovative,you should be attacking them on the quality of there products not all these useless things you talking about. i stand for empowerment and this i one african companies going places.not one person has ever said they have bad products.customising software is manufacturing by its self and well done astro.thats where it all begins this is what made china,they started by imitating but in as much as you say bad about them their are the richest country in world

    1. tawkats says:

      You are missing the point

    2. Munashe says:

      I used to have a Gtel and they are nice android phones. I heard Gtel started by immitating but now they build nice original phones

        1. Anonymous says:

          i like this reply. Munashe Gtel doesnt make original phones, unless there is such a thing as original fakes

    3. Elisha says:

      I’m also for empowerment, but not at the cost of our integrity. I refuse to believe that a Zimbabwean company has to straight up lie to be successful and that worse still, we have to accept it because they are local. If the 8 months of R&D were for software, they should have said so! No need to imply designing the phone from the ground up. If it is the slimmest device they have ever specced out and brought to market, they should say so! Claiming it’s the worlds thinnest phone without verifying such a simple fact just tarnishes the company and the local tech industry. They should be a success for what they are instead of a facade of half truths and lies. Lets hold each other up to a higher standard, truth is not useless.

    4. siya says:

      Yeah yeah…and you’re just one of them. Empty vessel. Innovative at lying.

  8. Anonymous says:

    Ana Mukuru263 what have you done that people can talk about mungoda varungu venyu chete, endai ku britain ka. musatinyangadzire vanhu vane zvavarikuita. kunyora pepa hazvirevi kushoropodza nguva dzose. Unotoshaya kuti zvinombo fambasei. I dont see astro knocking on your door step forcing you to buy. Vasiyei vakadaro. Itai zvenyu tione.

  9. Rumbi says:

    Munge munoshandira ana apple imi viva Astro viva Zimbabwe. Zimbabwe ndeyedu Astro ndeyedu

    1. Anonymous says:

      Nyika yedu haibudiriri ne attitude yakadai.

  10. Anonymous says:

    I agree With Mr Editor.They must just say they are a distributer of products untill they raise enough cash from the products they are distributing to actually Hire Physicists and engineers to design and make their own products. Nike Started out that way. Nike founder was importing sneakers from Japan and selling them from his car untill he generated enough cash to start developing his own Sneaker Range. There is nothing to be ashamed about if one starts out this way but please dont mislead the public.

  11. Yussuf Ouedrago says:

    This is pathetic journalism Mr kabweza, I am beginning ro think that you have something personal against these guys, It will be interesting if you share the root of the beef it with us your loyal readers. This article is not informative at all, it just shows your negativity towards some startups

    1. [email protected] says:

      Sorry to burst your bubble but,except for people like you who have an association with them,no one likes people who make false proclamations and mislead leaders and consumers.Its shady,unprofessional and a bit foolish to proclaim that you designed the thinnest phone and to actually dare to insult people by saying its “locally produced”.Who do you think you’re kidding? We won’t let you get away with misleading people and its good to set the record straight that no one in the tech community (except your people) endorses your untrue statements.

      I suggest you read on the Nhava liars. Your kin.

  12. gringo says:

    Bla Bla Bla Bla tech who basa kungochinja mazita.

  13. Nashe Munya says:

    Lies are not necessary guys. We will support them even without lying. This should be their 2nd year so we can’t expect them to be competing against your Samsungs, Apples, ZTEs or even Huawei. On another note they provided Powertel with the wifi models and the dongles. It is sad to say that I had to have two wifi modem replaced within about 4 months and finally had to go for the dongle. So in as much as you need support tell the truth.

  14. Munashe says:

    I wonder what they are going to say about my software when I release it

  15. Papa says:

    You hate them or like them but V2 ZVAZVINHU.iri kumberi

  16. Papa says:

    Why are you against ZIMASSET?

  17. TENDAI BITI says:

    We do not expect such malicious accusations .By the power invested in me i will make sure that i have this page removed IF THIS CONTINUES kikikikikik.

  18. TSVANGIRAI says:

    iWE BITI WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT…WHICH POWERS.,,LOL LMFAO.,.,.ASI V2 IRIKUMBERI WANGU

  19. Papa says:

    I got the V2 and i am loving it.Go get yours and taste it.Iri kumberi

  20. SOUJA LOVE says:

    Apa Hummer yangu haisati yadzoka sha.,,ahh ma1

  21. Baba jukwa says:

    Why are people so negative about local products…i personally got to look at the V2 and l was very much impressed…i think this is jst a plot to bring them down,,,Grow up

  22. patriotic zimbabwean says:

    i support astro 100%, i bought their new phone, the virtual II, it is great! but i do not support the lies.
    Mr Gwatidzo, please don’t lie to us, We will still buy your product because i believe in the vision you have for yourself and this great nation Zimbabwe, but the lies NO!
    about world’s thinnest phone {it is not} this phone is a replica of another phone, this sight published the article I some time ago
    WE will support you!!

  23. Baba jukwa says:

    Why are people so negative about local products…i personally got to look at the V2 and l was very much impressed…i think this is jst a plot to bring them down,,,Grow up

  24. Kungurirai says:

    I applaud TechZim for not joining the bandwagon of lies. Kutotiwo takaita R& D kikikiki, dai vangoti takaita market research. Pamwe kusaziva.

  25. Econet Hater says:

    WELL DONE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Great article. Expose the liars , then the world will be free of humans

    Am not a Christian but “He who hath not sin shall cast the first stone” lol….

    Always expose liars. And I’m not being sarcastic here.

  26. Anonymous says:

    Astro is doing a good job . Its producing a good quality phone that can compete with the best .But this does not give them the right to lie. I am one of the guys who support the local industry by actually buying their products. After the atrocious customer care service from Gtel after my A706 developed faults I am actually considering the Astro route. From the spec sheet this phone exceeds the Gtel A717 by far. Also a comparison with the V2 specs shows its a advanced copy of the V2. They did not need to lie. TechZim is correct to expose them. The lies will only detract people from an otherwise good product. They have been only a short time in the business and they are doing a fantastic job. I dont expect them to compete with the likes of Samsung and Apple in such a short time. if you have ever been short -changed you will never support people who lie. I need to buy knowing what I am buying.

  27. GudoGuru says:

    kabweza wd never be able to take down astro even if he tried,kkk,
    astro has many blind loyal customers who buy (&love) their over priced products at 500 hard earned dollars uchitoshaya kuti zvafamba sei, i doubt kabweza can convert and save all those lost sheep kkk

    and hanzi support local? word? i dont see anyone rallying behind vanhu vanohodha ma jean kuChina cz thats exactly what mr gwatidzo is doin -buyin and sellin asian goods
    i ain hatin, but astro is not a local product – period.

    aaaaaand this is a techblog i dnt think there is a more appropriate place to rant about such issues. iblog rake futi sakaaaaa…… Tanga Rako!! kkkk

  28. eli says:

    This article reminds me of what Strive Masiyiwa said in one of his facebook posts when he mentioned that in business you must never compromise your INTEGRITY. Though I think Kabweza could have expressed his point in much fewer words, his role in IT locally plus his Facebook/ Twitter following warrants that he speak out on Astro’s falsehoods despite how uneasy it may be !

  29. bledza says:

    I follow techzim closely, for three years now but I am surprised with kabweza’s hate of everything gwatidzo. I spoke to gwatidzo one day and he plainly told me that techzim dislikes astro brand and seek to diminish it at every turn and opportunity, then I disagreed with him but ow I know he was correct. its amazing that kabweza knows well that vana Samsung and Huawei vese vakatanga vachikopa. I my opinion you only seek to magnify the negative things that I agree they have done and do not give them equal credit. deny it or defend it all you can, kabweza wakamaka astro. ko tanga ka rako local brand tione kuti unizviita sei. I ead other articles on http://www.technomag.co.zw and thy bring out the same sentiment abt originalityof their product and claims but you can tell that the article does not carry a hate tone like kabweza’s. kabweza grow up and be a professional at your job my guy

    1. Raymond Swart says:

      Seriously, you’re OK with ASTRO claiming they developed the device? Rather than sent a chinese company their logo and wait a few months for the stock to arrive.

      As Limbikani states there is nothing wrong with coming up with a brand and being proud of it, just don’t con people by saying you built it when you didn’t.

      1. bledza says:

        even dairibord is manufacturing milk in sa and selling it here, who is lampooning them? its toll manufacturing, even ana Samsung and apple produce these gadgets out of their countries so as to cut costs of development

        1. Anonymous says:

          The issue here is LYING. Is it emotions, or does the zim tech community not understand english?

  30. Drogo says:

    Expose The Lies

  31. Raymond Swart says:

    Haha, ASTRO stop saying you developed the phone and just stick to the marketing of your branded device.
    Seriously!

    Limbikani, keep up the great work at Techzim we want real tech news not people trying to boost their own ego’s.

    1. Anonymous says:

      murikurwadzina itai enyu ka nhai. u cnt praise a journalist who put a Hollywood type of a headline like that. Limbikani usafurirwe nevanhu unodzorerwa kuMalawi

  32. tawaz says:

    Astro V2 is just a rebranded version the Chinese iNew V3. It retails at around $170 in China http://www.aliexpress.com/item/iNew-V3-Mtk6582-5-inch-Support-NFC-Smartphone-Android-4-2-Quad-Core-3G-GPS-RAM/1545703493.html

    1. purple says:

      And you sell it for $499 thats around 190% gross profit. Obviously after taking into account over in an extreme case it means your profit will be 100% conservatively. That god business sense. i applaude Astro for that. But making claimings which can easly be discredited by a simple google image search that unethical. What is worrisome is the mistake is more of stupid and you still want to stick to your guns? maybe u want us to get some callipers to truly measure the thickness?

  33. Parly Guy says:

    Astro should be taken to task for the lies. Imagine what our investors think? That we come up with ideas, get R&D funding but go backdoor to purchase the goods for rebranding and resale???
    We want this CEO in Parly for a Q&A session so that we set an example (not to mention the entertainment value from the discomfort of a liar)

    1. Ranga Chari says:

      go their yourself and see if they want their time wasted at parly Gay no i mean Guy

  34. Ranga Chari says:

    with all due respect i personal think the whole article is more personal attacking on Mr Gwatidzo which makes Mr Limbikani unprofessional. U are a star and motivate to many but i believe they cnt all not stand your unprofessional conduct with others. Starting with your headline its shows your foolishness and lack of maturity as a journalist. Maybe you are Mr almighty the greatest innovator. If he did change name to Astro its enough inovotions to be noted thn attacked foolish Limbikani

  35. Ranga Chari says:

    @ Parly Guy and Limbikani : Astro at their launch he point out that they integrate many things from others companies like Sony cameras. U can go around the world n not find a phone like that. go online check. what you can only find is a phone with similarities but not the actual phone with actual things. You u can join a battery from Samsung n LCD from Iphone and other things from different brands do you think you can find sm1 to claim it. Is thinking hard

  36. Anonymous says:

    THE Spirit working in you is not a good spirit. its called a spirit of destruction. You are after Gwatidzo and his establishment. You should be ashamed of yourself. its a demon in you that can easily say Lies-Damn Lies. They is no God in that no peace at all. You are agent of darkness plz repent for the kingdom of heaven is at hand. be nice be good build not destroy. Hebrews 12:14 ” follow peace with all men and holiness without which no man shall see the Lord” be in peace with him

  37. vaGudoguru says:

    If you lie about your product you should be called out. Journalists & bloggers would not be doing their job if their are not critical. It’s not the duty of Techzim to simply support nonsense simply because it’s a local product. If anything that’s the attitude that is stopping us from developing world class products and companies. And seriously, lets not defend this unprofessional behaviour by Astro. I would like them to succeed but not through peddling falshoods

  38. no kunyepa says:

    amana hatizi ma grade 2
    they put logo chete, if their design is stolen let them sue copycat

    R&D or market research kkkk

  39. Steve says:

    Astro is a joke

  40. Munashe says:

    What is A Visual Defence Analytical Mindstream?

  41. Anonymous says:

    this guy is just a distributor that has made enough sales to start putting a brand name on the gadget. i don’t see why people are saying we should be supporting him, after all these devices are not even designed in zimbabwe. I know all these phones but as different brands. even that astrobox isn’t his idea. Have a look at the Intel nuc or the AMD gigabyte brix. I am glad we have TechZim to help expose such dubious business practices that will ruin and tarnish the IT reputation in Zim. No harm in astro just focusing on marketing the device and they shouldn’t claim it is their idea. mxm

  42. INDEGRITI says:

    I agree with Anonymous that they are just a distributor that has managed volumes that enable them to put their logo on the merchandize. Much like the blank CDs and DVDs that many of us buy from Fainoos.

    Has Fainoos ever claimed to have set up a LOCAL manufacturing plant for blank disks?

    How can anyone seriously defend such uncouth business practices? We cannot grow as a nation if we defend such bad practices.

    Some want to compare this with Dairiboad producing Chimombe in South Africa but if you look at that case then you will see what integrity is. They have OPENLY stated that they prefer to make Chimombe locally but it is currently cheaper to have it toll manufactured in SA than to produce it locally by up to 20c per box. It is also CLEARLY written on the milk box that the milk is toll manufactured in SA so if you are a consumer who reads the packaging, you know what exactly it is that you are buying.

    The Astro Team needs to come out and tell the truth. They need to show that they are not pulling off a con like the NHAVA people that misled consumers and government. If their work was stolen they need to prove it to us otherwise they currently look like shameless liars.

    INTEGRITY IS KEY IN BUSINESS.

  43. moses says:

    viva astro

  44. moses says:

    pamberi nebasa mr Gwatidzo believe and your dream wiii come true

  45. nhava says:

    they are distributors but want to purport to be manufacturers; where is their plant

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.