No Jamie Dimon, Bitcoin is no fraud! You either don’t understand it, or you intend to deceive the people!

Posted by Read 5 Comments

This post was written by a Guest Author. The views expressed in this article do not reflect those of Techzim but of the Guest Author.

No Jamie Dimon, Bitcoin is no fraud. It’s either you don’t understand it, or you intend to deceive the people or both!

When I talk about crypto-currencies, I often draw on a quote by Wences Casares, a bitcoin entrepreneur. Casares says, “In Spanish, we have a saying that when a genius points at the moon, a fool looks at the finger. I find that happens a lot with Bitcoin.”

Jamie Dimon, Chairman and CEO of JP Morgan Chase seems to have mastered the art of barking at a moving rocket. In case you missed his comments, on 12 September 2017, Dimon called Bitcoin a “fraud”, while speaking at a conference. He further claimed that, “it’s just not a real thing, eventually it will be closed”. You can find the report in a CNBC article here. This is not the first time that Dimon has bashed Bitcoin. In January 2014, again speaking to CNBC, Dimon claimed that it is “… a terrible store of value. … It could be replicated over and over.” Back then, Bitcoin was trading at around $700. You can read the article here. The value of bitcoin has risen multiple times since then.

Advertisement

There are many plausible reasons why Dimon continuously attacks Bitcoin in particular, and crypto-currencies in general. Firstly, Dimon was born before computers (as we know them today). Secondly, he is probably just ignorant about Bitcoin and crypto-currencies, and how they work, in which case he should refrain from speaking authoritatively about things he least understands. Lastly, Dimon is a Wall Street banking executive running America’s largest bank, and earned himself $28.2 million in 2016 working for it. I believe that Dimon is frankly concerned that Bitcoin is slowly eating his lunch. To understand why this, we have to look at the drivers that led to the formation of Bitcoin.

It is widely agreed that the global financial crisis of 2007-2008 was caused by banks, triggered by the sub-prime lending crisis. The world watched in horror as banks either collapsed, merged or got bailed out in North America, Europe and Asia. Remember Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, Washington Mutual, AIG, Northern Rock, Merrill Lynch, Royal Bank of Scotland, Bradford & Bingley and Fortis among many others. The United States senate, in its Levin–Coburn Report concluded that the crisis emanated from “high risk, complex financial products; undisclosed conflicts of interest; the failure of regulators, the credit rating agencies, and the market itself to rein in the excesses of Wall Street.” You can find the report here. In the report, Dimon’s bank is cited numerous times.

When banks ruined their own industry during the financial crisis, they triggered a worldwide economic crisis, which left the global economy teetering on the brink of collapse. Many economies have not yet recovered from the effects of that crisis. Governments all over the world pumped trillions of taxpayer funds into banks to contain the domino effect. Typical moral hazard! But how did governments fund bailouts? They either used taxpayer funds, or printed the money. This printing of money is no doubt inflationary, and was couched in nice-sounding terms such as quantitative easing. The bank bailouts led to devaluation of fiat/government-issued currencies as well as currency wars – which still prevail to this day. Overall, this caused a net transfer of debt to the public purse. In short, banks defrauded taxpayers worldwide.  Therein lies the genesis of Bitcoin, a decentralized financial system that takes away power from a global elite like Jamie Dimon – the so-called one percent!

How does Bitcoin slowly chip away at Dimon’s lunch? Bitcoin is a decentralized peer-to-peer network. You don’t really need a bank to use it. Banks function as trusted third part intermediaries that run private ledgers which users never get sight of. It’s how they largely make their money. This has given them so much power that they can game and tank the global financial system. Satoshi Nakamoto and others realized a new financial system was necessary and invented blockchain technology, bringing about what in my view is the greatest innovation since the Internet in the 90s. Other than through the use of cash, Bitcoin makes it possible to make payments without JP Morgan Chase, or any other bank for that matter. Bitcoin’s decentralized ledger is public and can be viewed by anyone, including JP Morgan, whereas clients of JP Morgan have no clue what their bank’s ledger looks like or what the bank is up to. So, Jamie Dimon, it isn’t fraud! But let’s see who is a fraud!

Dimon joined JP Morgan in 2004. He was the CEO and chairman when the bank engaged in a plethora of wrongdoing and wheeler-dealing that eventually led to the global financial crisis of 2007-8 and subsequent printing of trillions of dollars across the world to bail-out banks. Dimon presided over the receipt by JP Morgan of $25 billion in bail-out funds from the U.S. Treasury in October 2008. The question is – what role did JP Morgan play in causing the global financial crisis under Dimon’s watch? 

William D. Cohan, a former managing director at JP Morgan, has written a detailed account of the case against JP Morgan in his article titled Jamie Dimon’s $13 Billion Secret: The inside story of JPMorgan Chase’s landmark mortgage settlement. You can find the article here. In short, under Dimon’s leadership, the bank manufactured and sold toxic mortgage-backed securities across the world. Cohan cites Wagner, a former US Attorney for the Eastern District of California, as saying, at JP Morgan, “the very due-diligence process that was supposed to be identifying bad loans and weeding them out was essentially being subverted or circumvented in the rush to get these to market.” According to Cohan, Wagner’s unfiled draft complaint against Dimon’s bank cited just ten examples of fraudulent violations by JP Morgan, but which “do not encompass the full extent of JPMorgan’s fraudulent scheme.” Pressured by the federal and state prosecutors, Dimon and his bank agreed in November 2013 to a settlement where his bank paid a record $13 billion “in a comprehensive settlement of mortgage-related securities claims”. It was the largest financial settlement of all time.

Dimon’s bank literally made billions out of knowingly bundling toxic assets and selling them off to unsuspecting investors. Now that is fraud. It’s a wonder he is not in jail.

What Dimon did not mention in his quip is that his bank has been widely testing and/or using the technology that Bitcoin brought about – Blockchain. In fact, JP Morgan has latched onto the technology and is running multiple blockchain projects. If Dimon understands blockchain and the immutable nature of distributed ledger technology to the point where he allows such technology at his bank – one wonders why he thinks a digital currency which brought about that technology and runs on that technology makes that currency a fraud. Is he out of touch with what’s happening in his bank, or he is just being disingenuous?

Dimon said that he would “fire in a second” any JPMorgan trader who bought Bitcoin, claiming that “it’s against our rules and they are stupid.” What is interesting though is that directly or indirectly, for themselves or on behalf of others, as was exposed by Twitter user @IamNomad yesterday, JPMorgan Securities Limited purchased 19102 bitcoins through a Swedish Exchange on 13 September 2017. You can find bitcoin holdings here (if they have not yet been sold or moved by the time of publication).

See below an image of the transaction.

Bitcoin

Bitcoin

We wait to see if Dimon will fire people within his organization who bought these Bitcoins after his statements since “it’s against our rules and they are stupid.”

And one more thing: I always hear people saying Bitcoin is used for illegal transactions. I always tell them that there is far more illegal stuff done using US dollars and other fiat currencies than in Bitcoin. At today’s market capitalization of $63 173 301 282, there is far more illegal stuff happening in fiat currencies all over the world than in any other currency. Are there scam-coins out there? Of course, there are. There will always be scams in the digital currencies space as there are in the fiat currencies space, and users of digital currencies need to understand and protect themselves.

If Dimon thinks that “…eventually [Bitcoin] it will be closed,” then be better get the best brains JP Morgan can buy to explain to him how it works. Bitcoin is here to stay. Bitcoin can’t just be shut down because it runs on a decentralized network with no single point of failure and it’s exactly why it’s designed that way. His statements are just akin to a dog barking at a shooting rocket. The barking won’t stop Bitcoin and blockchain from revolutionizing banking and finance.   

Taurai Chinyamakobvu is an enthusiast of blockchain, Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. He is an early stage investor and director of Bitfinance (a blockchain company), Flocash and Wezeshwa Fund. He is also an advisor to some international corporations. He can be contacted on tchinyamakobvu@gmail.com

Previous

School-type sciences were not for Phillip, the unconventional maker

Next

'I want to experience the product so that I give honest feedback to my audience' - Misred

5 Comments

  1. Sagitarr says:

    Fear of the unknown is driving government policies to regulate against the use
    of bitcoins, especially its recent spectacular rise over the $5000 dollar mark.
    This phenomenal rise has been likened to the tulip bulb investment craze of the
    16th/17th century. Based on that alone, some analysts are predicting a bubble
    burst for the bit coin whose value lost 30% in a week. This sentiment is also
    based on the fact that investment is not averse to risk-taking. No-one knows the future but we can only speculate on future probabilities by looking at past performance.

    Some links below might blow your mind on bitcoins.

    http://infocoin.net/en/2017/08/17/bitcoin-price-compared-to-tulip-bubble-according-to-bbc-tech-correspondent/

    https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/11/bitcoin-price-falls-on-reports-that-china-is-closing-local-exchanges.html

    https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/18/16326078/chinese-regulators-ban-cryptocurren
    cy-platforms-bitcoin

    In my view, the best analogy so far to demystify bitcoin was a remark that it is
    inefficient for it to gain widespread use in common transactions. It is like when you
    buy a litre of milk in a supermarket and several people have to “authenticate” that
    this $1.15 transaction is bona fide (i.e. the $1.15 is yours) before you walk away
    with the milk. On another note, what happens to the bitcoin technology should there be massive simultaneous prolonged disruption of power transmission across continents the likes we saw delivered by hurricane Irma or the Mexican earthquake which was higher than 8 Richter? What is the backup plan?

  2. TheKing says:

    I think there is nothing wrong with Dimon being a sceptic. He was wrong or had different opinions on some issues, but when you use the term fool, I think you are being emotional about Bitcoin. Maybe it’s because you have made a sizeable investment and you would like to see your investment grow.

    I understand the power of the Blockchain and I appreciate it. I have used Bitcoin to illegally take out my money ot of Zim and a lot of Chinese and Russians continue to do so. Bitcoin is definitely a good store of value now, noone knows what will happen in the future, maybe the price will continue to go up and you will make a killing on your investment.

    My issue with Bitcoin, not just amongst the Zim community, but in a lot of other countries as well is Bitcoin is not being used as a currency. It’s being used as an investment product. I have attended a few Bitcoin meetups in Harare and have been in a few Bitcoin Whatsapp groups. All I hear about is how the price is appreciating. Not that there is anything wrong with investing, but no investment is guaranteed. What if the value of that investment tumbles down just as it has gone up? This worries me. With all the hype about Bitcoin in Zim, it worries me that there is only one place where I can pay with Bitcoin i.e Techzim. I would like to have a situation where we use Bitcoin as a currency rather than as an investment product or as a way to take dollars out of our country.

    That being said, please go out and register to vote

  3. BTM says:

    I personally dont think Dimon is ignorant about bitcoin as you have stated in your article.I appreciate the impact of bitcoin etc.What i find a bit saddening as i have highlighted in the other articles on bitcoin on this platform is the approach taken by those that are mature in the crypto-currencies industry.That is you have turned rather to a defensive and attacking mode on anyone who dare says something opposite to how you view the bitcoin.Should you rather not take this opportunity to educate the masses than call people computer illiterate and ignorant(If you check all the comments on bitcoin articles on this platform you will understand were i am coming from).
    I am not against the use of bitcoin if you read into what Dimon said he does raise some valid points.
    1.its being used for illicit deals – is this not true?.
    2.It is currently unregulated but is this sustainable in the long run.(lets assume everyone is using bitcoin currently,without regulation it means people can avoid taxes etc.Taxes are the main source of govt revenue wether we like it or not but thats how govt gets money to deliver on other services and grow the economy).A scenario were this becomes a main stream currency and is unregulated is disastrous.
    3.”They will eventually be made as a payment system to follow the same standards as the other payment systems” – i can guarantee you that this is gonna happen.There are so many reasons why this is gonna happen but we can look at that in a different article.

    bottom line is:
    1.educate people do not call them fools and illiterate.
    2.Bitcoin has its advantages and disadvantages you need to educate people on both.e.g. like the banking sector has bitcoin also not created a group of elite traders with enough bitcoins to determine the shape of the industry? and how easily accessible is it to the majority,for instance rural Zimbabwe most of whom are as you have said about Dimon: “born before computers” or are “just ignorant about Bitcoin and crypto-currencies” ?.
    If you look at some of the few issues i raise already you have a same system like the banking sector only difference is one is not regulated

  4. Taurai Chinyamakobvu says:

    Your points are noted but seem to me misdirected (IMHO). Firstly, you assume we have not written material that educates readers on bitcoin. I have written articles on this myself, in the interest of simplifying it for readers. But that’s all we can do – those that do not know have a duty if they so deem, to want to learn about it, because like it or not, its revolutionising finance. You can take a horse to the river, but you can’t really get it to drink. Secondly, the education of the “masses” as you call them will happen over time. For reference on this, kindly read more about tech adoption and the S curves.
    Nobody said anything about anyone’s illiteracy – read the article again.Also understand the moon quote properly in its context.

    Also note that all currencies, including USD, Zambian Kwacha, Euro etc are used for illegal things – so that’s not unique to bitcoin. Bitcoin was invented in 2008-9. Before that, money as you know it was always used for all sorts of illegal things.

  5. Shufti pro says:

    Can Help financial services firms verify customer identity, and secure your Bitcoin based business to prevent consumer

    losses by identifying fake customers who deal with the businesses with the intention of committing theft.

Comments are closed.