If you were looking for cheap mobile data in Zimbabwe, where would you go? Are you sure your current data provider of choice is the very best or is it a matter of who is charging less?
Well in this article I shall be taking you on an expedition to get as close as possible to which service provider is the overall best. Think of it as a contest of networks. Let’s get to it.
The Contenders
The contest comprises of 4 of Zim’s most popular MOBILE data service providers that include Econet, NetOne, TelOne and Zol/Liquid. Specifically we are comparing their high volume data packages (2GB+). The packages are Private Wifi Bouquets (Econet), OneFi (NetOne), Blaze LTE (TelOne) and Wibroniks (Zol/Liquid).
The Categories
Price is not the only factor you should consider when choosing any product or service. And that’s why in this contest it’s one of the 5 categories which are:
- Device support: Works in which phones, routers or mifi devices
- Network Coverage: Which areas is the service available
- Selection: How broad is the product range
- Perks: What does each one of the packages have that make it attractive
- Price: We all know this one. Cheapest one wins
Ratings
Ratings are out of 5. 1 is a poor score in whatever category and 5 is the best score. At the end, scores of each package from all the categories are added up and the package with the highest score wins. Enough with the formalities. On with the show.
Device Support
| Econet Private Wifi Bouquets | NetOne OneFi | Zol Wibroniks | TelOne Blaze LTE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Works on all smartphones, LTE routers or Mifi devices that accept sim cards | Works on all smartphones, LTE routers or Mifi devices that accept sim cards | Works only on a few smartphones that support the ZOL Wibroniks LTE frequency band Works on most LTE routers and Mifi routers that accept sim cards | Works only on a few smartphones that support the TelOne Blaze LTE frequency band Works on most LTE routers and Mifi routers that accept sim cards |
| 5 | 5 | 3 | 3 |
Network Coverage
| Econet Private Wifi Bouquets | NetOne OneFi | Zol Wibroniks | TelOne Blaze LTE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Largest number of LTE base stations Largest Nationwide coverage | Second largest number of LTE base stations Second largest nationwide coverage | Available in parts of Harare and parts of Bulawayo only | Available in parts of Harare only. Service only available within 10km from the TelOne exchange the line was registered |
| 5 | 4 | 3 | 3 |
Selection
| Econet Private Wifi bundle | NetOne Onefi | Zol Wibroniks | TelOne Blaze LTE |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 packages to choose from 8GB, 15GB, 25GB, 50GB | Only 3 packages to choose from 25GB, 50GB, 80GB | 11 different packages 2GB, 3GB, 5GB, 10GB, 15GB, 20GB, 25GB, 30GB, 60GB, 100GB, Unlimited | 6 different packages 8GB, 15GB, 20GB, 40GB, 100GB, Unlimited |
| 6 | 5 | 5 | 3 |
Perks
| Econet Private Wifi Bouquets | NetOne Onefi | Zol Wibroniks | TelOne Blaze LTE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wide Network Coverage | 20% discount if you use OneMoney to buy any bundle | Largest selection of packages to choose from Unlimited package | Unlimited package |
| 3 | 4 | 2 | 1 |
Price Per GB
| Econet Private Wifi Bundles | NetOne OneFi | Zol Wibroniks | TelOne Blaze LTE | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest | Z$40/GB | Z$18.75/GB Z$15/GB (OneMoney) | Z$57.72/GB | Z$6.28/GB |
| Average | Z$51.95/GB | Z$23.25/GB Z$18.6/GB (OneMoney) | Z$92.83/GB | Z$50.62/GB |
| 2 | 4 | 1 | 3 |
Results
| Econet Private Wifi Bouquets | NetOne OneFi | Zol Wibroniks | TelOne Blaze LTE | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Device Support | 5 | 5 | 3 | 3 |
| Network Coverage | 5 | 4 | 3 | 3 |
| Selection | 3 | 2 | 5 | 4 |
| Perks | 3 | 4 | 2 | 1 |
| Price | 2 | 4 | 1 | 3 |
| Total | 18 | 19 | 14 | 14 |
Thoughts…
Well then. Looks like NetOne took it. But just by a point really so it was not a complete walk over. Thanks to the 20% discount when using OneMoney, NetOne eked out a win over the other 3.
Price comparisons are a headache when packages are not directly comparable. So the best way to do it was pick the price per GB but which one?
Well we took the best offering from all 4 in terms of price per GB so that we could get the lowest price per GB. In all the packages the most expensive package was the one with the lowest price per GB. This excludes unlimited bundles for obvious reasons.
Problem now is looking at the lowest price per GB alone does not show the full picture of which service provider has the most reasonable pricing across the board.
So we took the price per GB for each package offered by a service provider, added them all up for a particular service provider and came up with an average.
This average again does not include unlimited packages.
NetOne has the best bang for the buck here and if you need to get some data for that line you can just click on this link and pay using EcoCash for your convenience.
Updated 7 May 2020
Econet and NetOne both revised their offerings upwards resulting in their packages becoming a bit less attractive. This also means they both lost some points.
Econet lost a total of 3 points falling from a total of 19 to 16. 1 point was lost in the Selection category where it reduced it’s offering to just 2 options down from 3.
Private Wifi also lost 2 points in the Price category where it went from being one of the overall cheapest to literally the most expensive.
NetOne lost a point in the pricing category as well bringing it to 19. As much as this hit brought it closer to TelOne’s Blaze LTE and Zol’s Wibroniks, the drastic changes in the Econet Private Wifi bundle only increased NetOne’s lead against Econet.
Updated 30 May 2020
Econet added 2 new packages to it’s Private Wifi Bouquet offering bringing the total to 4 packages. This made it gain a point in the selection category.
NetOne lost a point in the same category with it’s OneFi as it now has the least number of options with just 3.
Regardless these changes are not enough to affect the positions. Overall NetOne’s OneFi is still the most favorable option in this space.
What’s your take? Cancel reply