You might be aware by now that Minister Supa Mandiwanzira is under investigation by the Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission. This is because of the report made by former NetOne CEO Reward Kangai alleging corruption and abuse of office on the minister’s part.
In his report, Kangai raises a lot of questions and points attention to some coincidences which are hard to ignore. In his account MetBank and its CEO, Ozias Bvute feature heavily in the story he calls ‘The Birth and Growth of a Cartel in the ICT sector in Zimbabwe.’
By ICT sector, Kangai means POTRAZ, NetOne, TelOne and Telecel, all organisations under the Ministry of Information Communication Technology and Cyber Security which Mandiwanzira heads.
Now hold on, what does Metbank have to do with Mandiwanzira building a cartel in the ICT sector? Kangai paints a picture with verifiable facts that is interesting. It does not appear like Mandiwanzira has a direct interest in Metbank but the facts seem to suggest that he is connected to the bank.
At the very least it seems like Mandiwanzira really thought Metbank executives were so good at their jobs he hired quite a number of them to various organisations under his ministry, chiefly NetOne and POTRAZ. Let’s look at the individuals connected to Metbank that were appointed to various positions in ‘the ICT sector’ by Mandiwanzira.
Peter Chingoka – the current NetOne chairman is actually still a non-executive director at Metbank. He was appointed director at NetOne by Mandiwanzira and later took on the role of Chairman when Alex Marufu vacated the post.
Sibusisiwe Ndhlovu – the current Chief Financial Officer at NetOne left her post as a director at Metbank to join the telecoms parastatal. Appointed by Mandiwanzira.
The big one. Bvute is the current CEO of Metbank and was appointed chairman of POTRAZ, the telecoms regulatory authority, by Mandiwanzira. He still holds the two positions.
When Bvute was appointed POTRAZ chairman, Metbank, the bank he heads as CEO owed POTRAZ $6.5 million. You could try to convince me that this does not count as conflict of interest but I would block out all you have to say on the matter.
Metbank also owed various other parastatals. They owed NetOne $300,000 [which had been reduced from $700,000 following legal action by Kangai who was CEO at the time as Kangai himself claims.] Zimpost was owed an unkown amount by the bank too.
As Kangai points out, both NetOne and Zimpost are all regulated by POTRAZ. So at the time when Metbank’s CEO was appointed chairman of the regulator POTRAZ, his bank owed the regulator itself and two of the organisations it regulates.
Metbank also owed other parastatals not under POTRAZ, POSB was owed $2m and Communications and Allied Industries Pension Fund (CAIPF) was owed US$1.6million when the Metbank CEO Bvute was appointed POTRAZ chairman.
It is public record that Bvute reinstated Alfred Marisa to his position as Deputy Director General at POTRAZ. Why had Marisa left his position? Then chairman Chikwenhere just said Marisa had left in an amicable manner which baffled many at the time.
Kangai claims Marisa had been fired for violating a board resolution which limited the amount POTRAZ could bank with Metbank to $500,000. If the limit was $500,000 it means Marisa exceeded that limit by $6m because when Bvute was appointed POTRAZ chairman, Metbank owed $6.5m. We have not verified this but if it’s true it is quite the revelation.
It would mean the Metbank CEO was appointed POTRAZ chairman and then he reinstated a director who had been fired for banking more money with Metbank than what the board had resolved was the limit.
Kangai alleges that Bvute instructed POTRAZ to purchase Crowhill stands worth $22.5m and that POTRAZ would only pay $16m, that is $22.5m less the $6.5m that was already owed by Metbank.
That deal if true is significant because Bvute owns Crowhill Farm which was subdivided into 4000 stands. Bvute won a High Court case which established him as the owner of Crowhill land in January 2015 and was only appointed POTRAZ chairman in April 2016. So essentially he was telling POTRAZ to buy stands from himself.
Bvute probably sold some of the his Crowhill stands to Metbank. The bank then used 85 of those stands as settlement of the $5m it owed Zimdef. It was reported that Zimdef lost millions in that barter deal as the stands were grossly overvalued.
It gets worse, Crowhill stands are developed by Tarcon (Pvt) Ltd. Mandiwanzira is known to be a shareholder in Tarcon.
Just why the parastatals kept and keep on banking with Metbank is a mystery. The bank owes most of these parastatals millions. Kangai alleges they do this because of coercion even as he alleges that even some of the management at these parastatals were pressured to open accounts with the bank in their personal capacity.
Telecel is one such organisation which banked with Metbank and was unable to withdraw its funds when it needed them to pay its licence fees. Metbank could not release $6m which had been deposited with them by Telecel and cited liquidity constraints.
Matigari has a theory as to why Metbank has survived despite all its scandals and huge debts. First, the CEO, Bvute is friendly with RBZ examination chief, Norman Mataruka. Which is why the RBZ ratified Bvute’s appointment as CEO of the bank in the first place despite him not having any banking experience.
Matigari goes on to link the bank to Robert Mugabe.
22/ My info shows that Kamushunda was involved in Goblin’s Malaysian deals
In 2013, Mugabe praised Kamushinda: “We have come a long way with him we have worked together in many places, like Malaysia and Namibia where he sometimes stays while doing projects to help the people,”.
— mmatigari (@matigary) January 3, 2018
Kamushinda is the founder of Metbank and Goblin refers to Mugabe.
The chairman of Metbank, Wilson Manase is the lawyer who represented Grace Mugabe in her diamond ring case. So it seems there was some sort of connection between the bank’s founders and officials with the former president’s family. This is probably why the bank has survived and also why parastatals felt compelled to bank with them.
There you have it. Some facts and allegations that place Metbank and its CEO, Ozias Bvute at the centre of #SupaGate, the Supa Mandiwanzira corruption scandal.